The cheap PC myth

A bit over one year ago I became a Mac user. You could say that I became a convert, though my household was still primarily a Windows shop, as I had three PCs to my one Mac.  At the time I decided to take the plunge into the Mac world, I chose the lowliest MacBooks as my first machine.

At the time I remember thinking that I was really paying a premium on a computer that didn't even have a DVD burner, but what the heck?  I wanted to have my own, first-hand, experience with OS X and Apple computers as I was already a convert to the iPod and was very happy with my third model.

It was a great experience.  Using a Mac is really easy and much less of a pain than a PC with Windows in many day to day tasks such as installing and removing applications.  For a bit over a year I used the Mac as my primary machine at home and moved everything I did to native Mac applications, except for my web development for which I use a Windows-only tool called Morfik.  I ran this software in a Parallels virtual machine with Windows XP, which worked like a charm.

Recently, as I was contemplating the computers I had at home and the use I, and my family, made of them, I was contacted by a friend that was taking a job abroad and that wanted to get a cheap notebook to take with him when traveling. He asked if I wasn't interested in selling him one of mine.

My own travel computer, an Asus EEE PC 1000HD, while a great little machine for a quick trip, is a bit underpowered being good enough for web browsing and email but not enough for any game that was released in the last couple of years. It also has a 10 inch screen and lacks a DVD drive which deprives you of  a nice way to pass away the time. 

As I considered this I came to the conclusion that the only machine I had which I would really recommend for such a situation, where he would be using the computer as his primary source of entertainment (he is going to be working on a tech project in Africa, in a place which hasn't got that many interesting entertainment options) was the MacBook.  My old Windows notebook, a nice looking Dell computer, hasn't got a working battery, as I've replaced it already three times and it is in need of replacement again.  My wifes'computer, another Dell notebook, while good enough for her web browsing and emails, isn't really up to the challenge of running anything but really old games and it weights well over three kilos.

So, there it was... the MacBook seemed like the perfect option.   While I didn't really need to sell him any computer, he was in a hurry to get a "traveling machine" and all the inexpensive options we could find were either underpowered or overweight.  

Having sold my Mac, I returned to using my Dell notebook and started to think about what would replace the MacBook as I can't really consider a three and a half year old Windows XP notebook without a working battery as my main personal computer.

When Apple announced it recent new lineup of products I was again attracted to the simple white MacBook as a replacement for my old one.  As I am in Brazil, while it is already listed in the online store, it is still not available for purchase.  This gave me time to wonder if, now that there is a new version of Windows, which I'm told isn't as bad as the previous one, it wasn't the time to reconsider my move to the Mac.  PCs are cheaper, after all.  While the global economic situation is showing signs of improvement, perhaps I should be prudent and choose a less expensive option and save a bit.

This reasoning took me to Dell's website to check out the notebook lineup.  I decided that the Latitudes, which are my current crop at home, where too expensive.  Just as I was choosing a plastic Mac, I could choose a plastic PC.  That would make it that much cheaper.  What do I care about this?  My personal computer is a notebook mainly for the mobility it gives me inside my home.  I work on a company computer for most of the day and take the EEE PC on trips.

So there I went to configure a Vostro 1320 with a decent processor, decent disk space and video options.  When I finished configuring the computer, it was about $50 cheaper than my choice MacBook, albeit it had 4 GB against 2GB of the default MacBook configuration.  The difference seemed small until I went back and really looked things over.  I was getting a slower processor, with a slower bus.  Slower memory and one "version" down on the graphics card, if the NVIDIA model numbers mean anything.  It didn't seem that good a trade off, but it was when I considered the battery that it really hit me.

My MacBook's battery, after fourteen months of usage was good for well over 2 hours of battery life.  My first Dell Latitude battery didn't even make it through the first year, being replaced under warranty.  The replacement, didn't last a full year and I ordered a new, larger, 9-cell battery which, in turn, lasted about a year.   Apple's new batteries have a much longer running time and are supposed to last a lot longer, five years if we are to believe the propaganda.   Well, I decided that if it lasts half that long, two and a half years, it makes the MacBook a bargain as replacing all those batteries isn't cheap at all.

So... I guess I'm off to get a new MacBook as my primary home system, throughly convinced that getting a PC wouldn't be cheaper at all.